4 min read

Thermal Cover

Discovering nature's security blanket
snow and trees
Dense stands of trees buffer the extreme temperatures that are experienced in open areas. Photo by David Lukas

I recently wrote about thermal cover for my Nature Notes newsletter, and I realize that some of you are hearing part of this story again, but this topic is so important that I want to dig a little deeper.

Extreme wildfires seem to be on everyone's mind these days, and one immediate reaction is that we need to log or thin forests to stop these fires. Unfortunately, when people hear about logging or thinning, they might think it's a reasonable way to prevent wildfires.

wildfire smoke
Wildfires are a fact of life these days. Photo by David Lukas

Surprisingly, the science on this is not clear. Some studies suggest that logging and thinning can help prevent fires, while other studies point to the ways that logging and thinning cause more fires, but one thing is clear: In the long-running debate about thinning forests, people are missing the fact that dense stands of trees provide a vital and irreplaceable service known as "thermal cover" (also known as thermal refuges).

dense stand of trees
Where other people see crowded trees, I see fantastic wildlife habitat. Photo by David Lukas

Think about thermal cover this way: If you're an animal, every day you face a life-or-death struggle to find enough food to stay alive. This makes it critical that you conserve every calorie possible by maintaining an ideal body temperature rather than wasting your energy trying to warm up in the winter or cool down in the summer.

dense stand of conifers
Dense stands of conifers are particularly good at holding heat on cold winter days. Photo by David Lukas

Denser stands of trees provide refuge from stressful temperatures for a huge range of plants and animals by blocking wind and holding heat in the winter, and by providing cool, moist shade on hot summer days. These lifesaving benefits help many species, and some plants and animals are utterly dependent on these kinds of habitats.

"Thermal refuges – thermally buffered locations where organisms avoid exposure to unfavorable temperatures – are emerging as one of the largest hopes for the persistence of populations during climate warming." Gibson et al.

However, denser stands of trees do much more than simply buffer temperatures throughout the year; they also provide places to hide or escape predators, including hiding spots where birds can nest, and deer can have their fawns.

whitetail deer
Because predators rely on "line of sight" while hunting, prey animals use dense cover to hide. Photo by David Lukas

And these are just some of the impacts that can be most easily seen or felt. Thinning denser stands of trees also changes soil respiration, vapor pressure deficits, and nutrient cycling, not to mention having profound impacts on tiny soil organisms that cannot survive or migrate to new areas when their habitats are suddenly opened up.

logging
Thinning as a fire management tool leaves vast areas with no thermal cover and no hiding places for wildlife. Photo by David Lukas

It seems particularly crazy that one of the main arguments for thinning is that the warming climate creates more extreme wildfires, yet people want to solve the problem by thinning trees, which causes forests to dry out and warm up even more!

logging
When you read about thinning in the news, this is what it looks like on the land. Ask yourself how many animals live here now? Photo by David Lukas

As a naturalist, I'm concerned that these broad-brush solutions will make the solutions far worse than the problems they're trying to solve. If we thin forests across entire landscapes, as the Forest Service is currently trying to do, then we put more stress on entire ecosystems and create a host of new issues that future generations will have to address. There are far better solutions than this.

🌲
There are many stories in the world that we rarely hear about, and I take my responsibility seriously to provide thoughtful coverage of these stories. Some topics are fun or amazing, and others deal with harder subjects, but they are all worthy of our attention. Please support me in this important work by upgrading to a paid subscription or by making a one-time donation. Thank you!